Comcast nightmare: 6 months with out World wide web regardless of $5,000 payment

Aurich Lawson | Getty Visuals

When Edward Koll and his girlfriend, Jo Narkon, acquired and moved into a new house in Draper, Virginia, in late September 2020, they had each and every explanation to assume that Comcast Internet would be quickly readily available.

They experienced finished their thanks diligence just before obtaining the dwelling, plugging the deal with into the Comcast website to make absolutely sure it experienced cable Online and contacting Comcast instantly to make more sure. Both the Comcast website’s availability checker and a Comcast income rep confirmed to them that the house experienced service.

But Comcast experienced specified the few fake information since of an error in its protection map, and it did not inform the pair about this error right up until just after they purchased the household. That was over six months ago, and Koll and Narkon still don’t have property Online provider.

“It was not until finally following we shut on the dwelling that Comcast finally notified us that we had been in a ‘dead zone,'” Koll told Ars when he very first contacted us on February 12, 2021. “The ends of our avenue are hooked up, but the middle where we live does not have the services pedestal.”

This wasn’t the to start with time that Comcast, the nation’s most significant cable organization, has falsely instructed consumers that services would be readily available.

Even however it was Comcast’s fault, the organization demanded $5,000 up front to extend its community to Koll and Narkon’s household. The couple sooner or later compensated up in late November after identifying it was the only feasible solution. But while Comcast originally promised assistance inside 90 times of acquiring the $5,000 payment, it unsuccessful to full the job in that time body.

Comcast now says the job will eventually be finished by April 15, in excess of six weeks immediately after the first 90-day estimate passed on March 2. The pair has been using cell hotspots for Net obtain the total time they have lived in the household simply because of Comcast supplying fake availability details and then failing to total the set up on time.

Comcast: “[We] did not reside up to our standards”

Comcast appeared to choose the difficulty much more seriously soon after Ars contacted the firm’s general public relations office, finally promising a $5,000 credit history.

“Mr. Koll’s experience did not live up to our standards and we are quite sorry for the inconvenience this has triggered, as a result, we will be implementing a credit history to his account equal to $5,000,” Comcast explained to Ars on March 29, soon after a few weeks of back-and-forth communication.

“The surprising element of it was Comcast’s refusal to even very own this,” Koll told Ars in a phone interview very last 7 days, after Comcast agreed to the $5,000 credit rating. “They just sort of brushed it off and we truly did not get any traction on this until we achieved out to you [at Ars].”

A Comcast rep referred to as the pair yesterday to confirm that services will be set up on Thursday, April 15, someday concerning 8 am and 10 am, Koll told us. Even right after that phone, Koll explained he is “not convinced” the task is far adequate alongside to be finished by then. But they have ordered Internet, Tv, and phone company, and the couple is switching their mobile phones in excess of to Comcast’s cellular services. The full cost is believed at $249 a month, Koll mentioned. At that value, the $5,000 credit history will last about 20 months. Virginia is 1 of the states where Comcast reluctantly agreed to hold off information-cap enforcement until finally 2022.

No choice but to pay back $5,000

Amongst e-mail, cell phone calls, and in-human being visits, Koll explained he experienced dozens of contacts with Comcast around the previous six months to try out to form the mess out. “Comcast stated, ‘yeah, our brokers advised you that services was accessible and they promised you that it was proper there at your doorstep, but they were being erroneous,'” Koll explained.

One installer arrived at the residence and, Koll explained to Ars, “said, ‘I want to go discover out the place your service line is,’ and then he disappeared. He hardly ever came again. And then we experienced two other installers and there was finally the 3rd male who stated, ‘You you should not have a service pedestal close plenty of and you might be seeking at a hefty bill just to have it put in.'”

Right after hearing Comcast’s demand from customers for $5,000, Koll complained to the FCC, but the agency “adopted up with Comcast and accepted their explanation without remark,” Koll told Ars. Koll explained he also contacted the offices of US Sens. Tim Kaine (D-Va.) and Mark Warner (D-Va.) without the need of any success.

Edward Koll at his home.

Edward Koll at his property.

Gigabit World wide web “is obtainable for your address”

Koll presented Ars a duplicate of the $5,000 bill dated November 30 together with chat and e-mail transcripts from conversations he had with Comcast.

In an on the internet chat ahead of they bought the residence, Koll questioned a Comcast rep to validate that gigabit Net provider and cable Tv set would be accessible. The rep informed him that “the Gigabit Speeds Web system is accessible for your handle” and that a 2-calendar year contract would price tag “$169.99/mo additionally equipment, taxes, and charges.”

The rep explained to Koll to purchase provider five to 8 company days in progress in circumstance cable necessary to be operate to the household, building it seem like it would be an simple method and not a 6-month ordeal. But the Comcast rep was improper since Comcast’s system was offering untrue details. Koll put an buy for Comcast services around the cellular phone on August 25, and the few shut on the property on September 24, moving in the exact same day. Even when accepting the order, Comcast didn’t realize that it hadn’t prolonged its network shut ample to the residence to offer services.

Comcast boasts about its gigabit network in a slide from a press kit.

Comcast features about its gigabit network in a slide from a push kit.


On November 1, 2020, Koll replied to an electronic mail from a Comcast rep in the govt client relations section and pointed out that Comcast’s support map showed his handle as acquiring services. Koll’s e-mail also pointed out that he had placed an purchase for provider on August 25 “and at the same time place a deposit into the account so that service would be put in on or right before closing on this residence.”

“Offered the numerous assurances from Comcast for company and the lengthy delays we have by now endured, I anticipate a swift resolution to this matter,” Koll wrote in that e-mail.

But there was no swift or cheap resolution. “We reluctantly agreed to shell out $5,000 in November to have the support pedestal put in even with Comcast’s earlier promises regarding current company availability,” Koll informed Ars, months later.

“We genuinely will need help”

Koll initial contacted us after reading a single of our content about a 90-yr-aged AT&T client, Aaron Epstein, who bought an advertisement in The Wall Street Journal to complain about AT&T’s slow World wide web assistance. At the time, Koll was not guaranteed that Comcast would set up services at all.

“We definitely have to have aid, very similar to Mr. Epstein,” Koll explained to Ars in his very first email to us. “We need to have to get the service we have been promised mounted. We would like to have the $5,000 again, but at this level are eager to take that as a credit to future bills. Comcast has made available two totally free months, which does not appear near to the sum we have compensated.”

While Comcast later agreed to a credit rating equal to the comprehensive amount they compensated, the company did not inform us why it will not refund the $5,000 as an alternative of providing it as a bill credit score. That effectively signifies they experienced to pay out $5,000 in advance for about 20 months of services, an initial cost that new Comcast customers usually would not have to shell out.

Comcast fixes map, months as well late

In late March, Comcast ultimately up to date its protection map and on the web availability checker to appropriately present Koll’s address as unserved. So why did Comcast’s web-site and a Comcast profits rep falsely notify Koll that service was now offered at the home?

“This is not a widespread incidence and we have to appear into these circumstances on a circumstance-by-case foundation,” Comcast explained. “For this specific handle, it was integrated in a database from a firm we obtained lots of many years back. Our regional groups are setting up a further more assessment of that regional databases.”

Cable organizations have unsuccessful for many years to establish much more precise services maps. The cable industry’s major lobby team fought against specifications to post deal with-stage knowledge to the Federal Communications Commission, telling the FCC in 2017 that it is way too challenging and high-priced to determine out specifically wherever they can and are not able to provide provider.

The FCC eventually purchased ISPs to post geospatial maps of where by they give company in 2019, but then-FCC Chairman Ajit Pai did not end environment up the new system just before leaving place of work in January 2021. On having over from Pai, acting FCC Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel uncovered “that we had a lot of work to do and hadn’t nonetheless started many of the actions expected to really develop a assortment system,” she wrote.