28/07/2021

helps make very first payment in $1.5M whistleblower scenario

The Jackson County town of Pendergrass has about 3000 citizens. They will have to start paying out a $1.5M judgment.

It took almost a dozen several years, but the metropolis of Pendergrass has designed its 1st payment on what’s developed to a $1.5 million judgment from a whistleblower lawsuit.

Unfortunately, a single of individuals whistleblowers did not stay to see any of the income.

The FOX 5 I-Staff initially broke the tale in 2009. Former city clerk Katherine Rintoul and police Lt. Invoice Garner experienced warned the mayor that metropolis supervisor Rob Russell was repairing targeted traffic tickets and misspending tax money. 

Russell denied individuals allegations.

As a substitute, Mayor Monk Tolbert fired Rintoul. Garner later on stop claiming a hostile work surroundings.

It would take 8 decades to get their whistleblower situation to trial. A Jackson County jury awarded the pair $1,056,000 in damages and back again pay out. 

So what did Pendergrass do? Refused to pay … for another 3 a long time.

With interest setting up at $93,000 a calendar year furthermore attorney’s charges, the volume Pendergrass now owes is all around $1.5 million.

Pendergrass stored city manager Rob Russell after employees complained he was fixing tickets and misspending money. As an alternative, the staff were fired.

In April, right after missing the deadline to file their last attraction, the town wrote its first look at for damages: $50,000. City manager Russell stated they’ve since mailed a next $15,000 check.

The whistleblowers have set a June 18 deadline for the city to arrive up with a payment prepare.

“We’re providing them some time to determine it out,” reported legal professional Nancy Val Preda. In correct David and Goliath fashion, she bested a staff of attorneys hired by the city.

“They’ve constantly preserved we have been erroneous and the jury received it mistaken,” she claimed.

Pendergrass has found dramatic progress considering that the whistleblower lawsuit was submitted 12 years ago. The elevated consumer service fees and house taxes from new warehouses and neighborhoods are envisioned to enable fork out the judgment.

All around 3,000 folks are living in Pendergrass. This year’s spending plan is $908,650. Nonetheless the plan is to shell out off the judgment with no elevating taxes or cutting companies.

“It’s going to be tough for us to spend it,” stated Russell. “We. Will. Shell out it.”

Ready a few a long time may well have price tag the city far more income, but it has also furnished a larger sized tax base. Since then, several subdivisions have sprung up, along with millions of sq. toes of warehouse house.

In fact, tax revenues have doubled considering the fact that the whistleblower lawsuit was submitted 12 several years in the past.

“Our objective is to minimize this in fifty percent inside 24 months,” vowed Russell.

Pendergrass by now mortgaged its metropolis corridor making to include the around $500,000 billed by their personal lawyers for the lawsuit.

Previous city clerk Katherine Rintoul (L) and Monthly bill Garner’s widow Jennifer hope the lawsuit has created Pendergrass fork out closer attention to expending and ethics regulations.

Was this kind of an highly-priced, drawn-out combat worthy of it? For either side? And has anything transformed?

Rintoul said above the years she frequently questioned about her conclusion to appear forward.

“I couldn’t,” she stated. “I could not just be tranquil and wander away.”

And when the doubts seemed overwhelming, she explained her fellow whistleblower often assured her they did the suitable detail.,

“I had Invoice to converse to,” explained Rintoul. “To bounce things off.”

Invoice Garner. For several years, his controversial departure from Pendergrass created it difficult to get yet another task in legislation enforcement.

But previous summer months, ultimately operating once again as a deputy for the Franklin County Sheriff’s Workplace, Garner responded to a a person-car or truck accident on Interstate 85.

It was dark. The highway, slick. As the 52-12 months-previous walked back again to his patrol motor vehicle, an additional driver missing handle and skidded into him. Garner died on affect.

“I wish he could have witnessed this minute but I know he’s with us,” stated his widow Jennifer. “I know he’s right here. I converse to him every single day.”

Previous Pendergrass law enforcement lieutenant Invoice Garner did not live to see the initial payment. The Franklin County sheriff’s deputy died final calendar year in the line of obligation.

In the yrs subsequent the lawsuit, Pendergrass ongoing to draw in damaging interest. Much more allegations of corruption and conflicts of interest.

Mayor Monk Tolbert’s family has held essential political positions in Pendergrass for generations.

Before this calendar year, as Pendergrass ongoing its shedding lawful battle in opposition to the whistleblowers, state lawmaker Tommy Benton introduced HB 222, built to end the controversy once and for all.

“This bill does a single issue,” the Jefferson consultant explained to a Property subcommittee. “It abolishes the charter for the city of Pendergrass. Right now they’re a mess. And we don’t have any other way to resolve that correct now.”

Rep. Tommy Benton, R-Jefferson, represents the Pendergrass region. He was so fed up with allegations of corruption and ethics violations he asked the Normal Assembly this yr to dissolve the city.

Benton also doubted the metropolis could shell out the judgment. Nonetheless, the whistleblowers concerned if the town disappeared, so would their tricky-fought damages.

Pendergrass people implored lawmakers to give their town yet another possibility.

“Factors are unique today,” testified Meredith Davison. “The city is a unique area nowadays.”

Pendergrass Mayor Monk Tolbert urged lawmakers not to dissolve the city he and his family have operate for generations. He received his desire.

In March, the mayor promised lawmakers the town could pay any judgment.

“We’ve presently gathered income to go to that … if we reduce,” he explained. “But I’m self-assured that we’re not likely to eliminate.”

The mayor’s self esteem was misplaced. The following month Pendergrass did lose their final attraction soon after it was not submitted on time.

As for the struggle about their charter, Pendergrass did handle a cease-fireplace. Lawmakers decided to keep off for an additional yr on whether Pendergrass ought to keep on being a city.

Athens attorney Nancy Val Preda took the whistleblower circumstance on contingency, with no warranty she would be compensated unless she received. Twelve several years later on, she and her shoppers noticed their 1st examine. 

Tolbert would not answer to queries for this tale, referring the FOX 5 I-Workforce to city supervisor Russell.

“We definitely feel that after this is accomplished that the conclusion final result is that our cityhood won’t be challenged once more,” Russell stated.

He also insisted he’s no for a longer period in private organization with the mayor, 1 of the major apparent conflicts of interest criticized by point out lawmakers.

To support pay the judgment, Russell reported there will be no raises or expansion of metropolis services. But no new taxes both.

Val Preda claimed her consumers have been open to a settlement provide due to the fact 2009, but no one ever referred to as.

Rintoul options to use revenue from the initial look at to pay payments and take a loved ones holiday. Now that her partner has passed absent, Garner mentioned the lawsuit proceeds have become her sole source for retirement.

“This has been a extensive time coming,” Val Preda said. “And they by no means, at any time, at any time acknowledged what they did was wrong.”

That possible will in no way, ever come. When we requested Russell if he had any apology — even to the metropolis of Pendergrass – he declined.

“I just would like this did not happen,” he reported.

Check out: FOX 5 Atlanta live information protection

_____

Indication up for FOX 5 e-mail alerts

Down load the FOX 5 Atlanta application for breaking news and weather alerts.